Edit proposed-hooks-2026-05-06.md

All Files › wiki › content › drafts › queue › proposed-hooks-2026-05-06.md

📝 wiki/content/drafts/queue/proposed-hooks-2026-05-06.md

View rendered → Unsaved

---
file: content/drafts/queue/proposed-hooks-2026-05-06.md
purpose: agent batch 2 — 7 hooks for Ansis 9 AM review
brand: gotauts
generated_at: 2026-05-06T11:55Z
generator: content-agent v1.0 (in-session, batch 2)
status: pending-review
---

# Proposed hooks — 2026-05-06 (batch 2)

## LEARN pass findings

- **Top-quartile lookup:** performance log still empty (no carousels published yet). No data-driven winners to bias toward — same fresh-basis state as batch 1. **Recommend: publish at least one carousel before batch 3 so LEARN has signal.**
- **Under-served scan:** batch 1 mix was 28% V / 57% O / 14% S vs target 30 / 50 / 20. Operator slightly over-weighted (+7 pts), Validator and Scaler each slightly under. All within ±10pt band, but batch 2 should pull Operator slightly back toward target rather than re-skew further.
- **Signature cooldown:** no published carousels in last 7 days — all 10 voice signatures from `messaging.md` available. Batch 2 reaches for fresh signatures over batch 1's "Cashflow is a skill" line.
- **Loser autopsy:** no bottom-quartile data yet.
- **Formula coverage from batch 1:** H5 untested. Batch 2 covers H5. **H6 (What's Worse?) tested in batch 1 — resting in batch 2 to see batch-1 H6 perform first.**
- **NEW THIS BATCH:** `wiki/content/visual-references.md` added to READ FIRST. Hooks now actively bias toward Caleb's viral pattern: cover-dominant + personal arc + specific count + trust-hack ("not what gurus say") + restraint on emphasis. Each hook below cites which Caleb pattern element it leans on.

---

## H1-Authority — [Validator]

> *"My first sale took **90 days**. The next $5M took **12 months**. Velocity is not speed."*

```
basis:
  - perf: first 14 days, no perf data; fresh — pattern weighted toward Caleb R1 (personal arc + contrarian close)
  - signature: none — fresh; "velocity is not speed" candidate signature for messaging.md if it lands
  - icp_pain: Validator's "I am too late" anxiety; reframes the slow start as part of the build
  - caleb_pattern: cover-dominant personal arc + contrarian one-liner close
draft_id_proposed: 2026-05-06-h1-velocity-not-speed
```

---

## H2-Steps-Controversial — [Operator]

> *"I run e-comm at **$1M+/month**. The **4 numbers I read before 11am** are not what every guru tells you to check."*

```
basis:
  - perf: first 14 days, no perf data; fresh
  - signature: none — fresh; trust-hack frame ("not what every guru")
  - icp_pain: Operator's overreliance on ROAS as the diagnostic; need for upstream metrics
  - caleb_pattern: authority stake ($1M+/month) + specific count (4) + trust-hack ("not what every guru")
draft_id_proposed: 2026-05-06-h2-four-numbers-before-11am
```

---

## H3-Trending-Guide — [Scaler]

> *"US expansion as a non-US founder in 2026. Bank, EIN, warehouse, payments. **A field guide for stores past $1M.**"*

```
basis:
  - perf: first 14 days, no perf data; fresh
  - signature: none — fresh; uses Jacksonville warehouse opening as proof
  - icp_pain: Scaler's "what's the unlock to 8 figures" — geography is one real lever
  - caleb_pattern: trending topic (US expansion 2026) + scoped list + "for whom" filter
draft_id_proposed: 2026-05-06-h3-us-expansion-field-guide
```

---

## H4-Desire-Proof — [Operator]

> *"How to read your e-comm P&L in **6 minutes a day** and still scale. Backed by **the December I just closed at $1.15M**."*

```
basis:
  - perf: first 14 days, no perf data; fresh
  - signature: echoes "OUR FIRST $1M+ MONTH" (in-market A1, December)
  - icp_pain: Operator's drowning-in-spreadsheets problem; specific time promise (6 min) is the relief
  - caleb_pattern: specific time promise (6 minutes) + real proof receipt ($1.15M)
draft_id_proposed: 2026-05-06-h4-six-minute-pnl
```

---

## H5-NotTheWay — [Operator] · NEW formula tested this batch

> *"**Discounts are not** how you fix a 0.43 ROAS day. **A clean AOV trend is.**"*

```
basis:
  - perf: first 14 days, no perf data; fresh — H5 formula untested in batch 1
  - signature: none — fresh; pivots from a wrong instinct (discount) to a right diagnostic (AOV)
  - icp_pain: Operator's panic-discount reflex on a bad ROAS day; misreads the data
  - caleb_pattern: pivot frame; restraint on emphasis (one phrase per side of the pivot)
draft_id_proposed: 2026-05-06-h5-discounts-vs-aov
```

---

## H7-Stat-Steps — [Validator]

> *"**9 out of 10** new Shopify stores never see a $10K month. The 5% that do share **the same 3 habits I had in Year 1 to $5M**."*

```
basis:
  - perf: first 14 days, no perf data; fresh
  - signature: none — fresh; uses $5M Y1 receipt as proof
  - icp_pain: Validator's "is it worth it" hesitation; pattern-of-habits is more accessible than tactics
  - caleb_pattern: stat hook (9 of 10) + scoped count (3 habits) + personal proof ($5M Y1)
draft_id_proposed: 2026-05-06-h7-five-percent-3-habits
```

---

## H8-Signs-Protocol — [Operator]

> *"**5 signs** your bottleneck is cashflow, not ROAS. **The 7-day protocol** that paused $810K in payouts and shipped Wednesday anyway."*

```
basis:
  - perf: first 14 days, no perf data; fresh
  - signature: indirect echo of "Cashflow is a skill, not a result" + the actual paused-payouts receipt from the in-market post
  - icp_pain: Operator's misdiagnosis of bad days as ROAS issues when cashflow is the real problem
  - caleb_pattern: signs + protocol promise + personal receipt ($810K paused, shipped Wednesday) — strongest Caleb-fit in this batch
draft_id_proposed: 2026-05-06-h8-cashflow-not-roas-protocol
```

---

## Sub-persona mix achieved

| Sub-persona | Target | This batch | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Validator | 30% (~2/7) | 2 (H1, H7) | ✓ on target |
| Operator | 50% (~4/7) | 4 (H2, H4, H5, H8) | ✓ on target |
| Scaler | 20% (~1/7) | 1 (H3) | ✓ on target |

Same balanced mix as batch 1 (29 / 57 / 14). All within ±10pt of target.

## Formula coverage

| Formula | Batch 1 | Batch 2 | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| H1 Authority+Problem+Take | ✓ | ✓ | tested twice |
| H2 Authority+Steps | ✓ | ✓ | tested twice |
| H3 Trending+Guide | ✓ | ✓ | tested twice |
| H4 Desire+Proof | ✓ | ✓ | tested twice |
| H5 X-not+But-this-is | ✗ | ✓ | first test |
| H6 What's-Worse | ✓ | ✗ | resting after batch 1 |
| H7 %Struggle+Steps | ✓ | ✓ | tested twice |
| H8 Signs+Protocol | ✓ | ✓ | tested twice |

7 of 8 formulas tested twice. H6 covered once in batch 1 — needs a published post before next test.

## Caleb-pattern alignment (NEW this batch)

Each hook above explicitly cites which element from `wiki/content/visual-references.md` it leans on:

- **Cover-dominant arc:** H1 (90-day to $5M)
- **Authority + specific count + trust-hack:** H2 (4 numbers, "not what gurus")
- **Trending topic + scoped list:** H3 (US expansion guide)
- **Specific time promise + real proof:** H4 (6 minutes, $1.15M)
- **Pivot frame + restraint:** H5 (discounts vs AOV)
- **Stat + count + personal proof:** H7 (9 of 10, 3 habits, $5M Y1)
- **Signs + protocol + receipt:** H8 (5 signs, $810K paused) ← strongest Caleb-fit

The two strongest Caleb-pattern hooks (H8 and H4) are the ones I'd push to expand first — they have the best "cover does 90% of the selling" potential.

---

## PROPOSED UPDATES

```
PROPOSED UPDATES:
  - file: ops/agents/content-agent/changelog.md
    change: log batch 2 generation + note that visual-references.md is now active
    rationale: voice/strategy edits should be auditable; this is the first batch reading the new file

- file: wiki/business/brand-book/messaging.md
    change: consider adding "velocity is not speed" to voice signatures if H1 lands top quartile
    rationale: candidate fresh signature, not yet in messaging.md, internally consistent with the stoic-builder cadence

- file: ops/flows/content-engine.md
    change: surface the "publish before batch 3" recommendation explicitly in the Phase-1 transitions
    rationale: 2 batches without a published post means LEARN pass has no real signal — engine is generating in the dark
```

## Ansis 9 AM review checklist

- [ ] 7 hooks present
- [ ] Each has a `basis:` line including new `caleb_pattern:` field
- [ ] Sub-persona mix within ±10pts of target (this batch: 2/4/1, exact)
- [ ] At least one hook from H1, H4, or H8 — ✓ all three present
- [ ] No banned phrases (em-dashes-as-commas, hyphen-conjunctions, fluff)
- [ ] Frozen CTA verbatim — N/A this batch (hooks-only; CTA appears in expansion)
- [ ] PROPOSED UPDATES section present — ✓
- [ ] H5 actually tested for the first time — ✓ (H5-NotTheWay)

To approve: mark ✓ next to the `draft_id_proposed` you want expanded into full carousels. Strongest Caleb-pattern picks: **H8** and **H4**.

Ctrl/Cmd+S to save

👔

CEO Agent

Ready

I can add people, log decisions, save ideas, and read any cabinet file. Try: "add me as CEO of YGH", "log decision: school kits build or partner by May 30", or "save idea: rep gifting tour for greenhouse kits". I'll write to the right file and confirm.

now